I ran into some examples of a shortcoming in our current educational system. The sort who has very strong opinions (good), is generally well informed (good) but doesn't know how to ARGUE.
They like ad hominum attacks. They use broad generalities to fit their opponents into neat boxes. The throw in profanity for effect and reaction, and then retort with " its just a word".
Unfortunately, they enjoy hearing their own voice and punctuation only in a media where retaliation is not a risk. I wonder if they would be so cavalier in expressing their opinions and vitriol in a public space.
I actually agreed with most of the thoughts expressed by the people engaged in this conversion. It was just their way of "killing their compatriots". They accused the person ask us pray for the troops of being a hypocrite because her husband had a "cushy stateside posting" and wasn't getting shot at. They attacked a poster who said she was frustrated by the Phelps- First Amendment decision (protesting at military funerals) and sometimes wishing she could put those people on an ice floe for calling themselves Christians. They said she was "encouraging violence" against people with different opinions.
I was accused of being ageist - because I requested more civil discourse ... and a "boomer that was responsible for the type of thinking that got us into Iraq & Afghanistan in the first place". Well, to set the record straight, I guess I am a "barely Boomer", and as a Catholic and a pacifist in general, nope, don't think my opinions are properly reflected by Don Rumsfeld and Dick Cheney. But, I also believe this does not stop me from praying for the soldiers serving or the civilians in those areas. Or of thinking that the Phelps group protesting at funerals as being crass and in poor taste.
I wish our educational institutions would go back to teaching classics - rhetoric, logic, ethics... Logical, thoughtful discourse is a rare commodity. I want the next generation to argue their beliefs with passion and not with malice. I want clarity of thought; not "hot buttons" and sound bites.
And I can put blame only one place - right here. People like me who tolerate such boorish behavior. Encourage it even by supporting Glenn Beck, Rush Limbaugh, and Howard Stern. Stop reading the paper and expect our information in 15 minute increments and CNN instant updates. Look to Fox News and MSNBC to interpret world event for us.
WE all need to be informed. Read History, Read the paper. Listen. Know both sides of an issue. Listen to your opponent. Not to destroy them, but to influence them.
Its not as fast; but it last longer.